Two colleagues reviewing an employee benefits document together at a desk.

How to Talk to Your Employees About Open Enrollment

Quick Summary: Open enrollment communication works best when it starts a few weeks before the enrollment window opens, explains what is changing and what is staying the same, uses everyday words instead of benefit terms, and gives employees a clear place to ask questions. A short announcement followed by steady reminders helps people choose on time, and it helps your team avoid a rush of questions in the final days.

Every fall, HR teams put in serious work for open enrollment. You compare plans, sit through lengthy renewal meetings, and build out a detailed enrollment guide. You send the big announcement email—and then most employees skim it for ten seconds and go right back to work.

The disconnect usually comes down to how the details are shared. Your employees are busy, and benefit terminology can feel like a foreign language. To most, last year’s plan feels like the safest choice, even if the plan details have shifted underneath them.

Good open enrollment communication doesn’t require a marketing campaign. It just requires an early start, plain language, and a few well-timed reminders. We partner with employers across Western New York on this every year, and the pattern is remarkably consistent: companies that communicate early enjoy calmer enrollments and far fewer last-minute questions.

Here’s the communication strategy we use with our commercial clients at Walsh.

1. Start before the window even opens

Your first message should land three to four weeks before enrollment begins. You aren’t asking anyone to make a choice yet. You’re simply sharing the dates and setting expectations so your team can plan around them.

Before that first message goes out, brief your managers. Employees naturally take their first questions to their direct supervisors. A manager who knows the timeline can give their team the grace to review the guide during the workday. A manager who gets caught off guard will just wave people back to HR, causing a bottleneck at your desk.

2. Lead with what’s changing

When employees read enrollment material, they are really just looking for two answers: Is my plan changing? And what will it cost me?

Put those answers near the top of every message you send.

It’s equally important to say what is staying the same. If the medical plan design hasn’t changed and only the payroll deduction moved, state that plainly. People relax when they know the core parts they rely on are staying put.

When a cost does change, put the old number and the new number right next to each other, broken down by pay period. A percentage increase is hard to visualize. A concrete dollar amount coming out of a bi-weekly paycheck is something an employee can weigh immediately.

3. Speak their language

Benefit terms are second nature to HR professionals, but they’re confusing to almost everyone else. When a term really matters to a decision, explain it in the exact same sentence.

For example: A deductible is the amount you pay for care before the plan starts paying. That single clause carries more weight than a glossary at the back of a 20-page PDF. Keep your paragraphs short and use headings that clearly explain what the section covers.

4. Show the true cost of a choice

The payroll deduction is the number employees compare first, but it’s only part of the story. A plan with a smaller deduction can carry a much higher deductible—meaning an employee who uses care regularly might end up paying far more over the year on the “cheaper” plan.

Give your team a simple way to compare the two numbers side by side: what comes out of the paycheck over the year vs. what they could pay out of pocket for care. Your Walsh advisor can help you build these comparisons using your real plan designs and rates, rather than national averages that mean little to your team.

5. Send it more than once, in more than one place

One single announcement email won’t satiate an enrollment season. Plan a short, steady sequence instead:

An early notice with the dates.

A message the day enrollment opens.

A midpoint reminder for anyone who hasn’t started.

A final reminder that states the closing date clearly.

Put the message where people will actually run into it. Email works for office staff, but a posted notice near the time clock reaches the floor. Manager huddles cover the employees who rarely open email at work.

6. Make questions easy to ask

Many employees aren’t comfortable asking about deductibles or prescriptions in a crowded group meeting. Give them a specific, named person to contact and a private way to ask questions (via email or a direct phone line). Giving them a direct point of contact goes much further than simply saying “our door is open.”

Remember that many employees make these decisions at the kitchen table with a spouse or partner. Providing a take-home guide, or hosting an information session that partners are welcome to attend, leads to more confident choices and far fewer change requests come January.

7. Close the loop

When the window finally closes, send a short confirmation message. Tell employees how to verify that their elections went through, and remind them to check their first January paycheck to confirm the deduction matches what they chose.

Tell them when to expect their new ID cards and exactly who to call if a card doesn’t show up. This simple message prevents a steady trickle of worried phone calls in the first weeks of the new year.

A Simple Communication Timeline

Four weeks out: Tell employees the enrollment dates are coming and brief your managers.

Two weeks out: Send the guide, with the changes clearly summarized on page one.

Opening week: Send the announcement with the deadline stated in the first two lines.

Midway through: Remind anyone who hasn’t enrolled, and hold an open Q&A session.

Final two days: Send one last reminder naming the closing date and the contact for help.

After the close: Confirm elections and explain what happens next, including ID cards.

How Walsh Can Help

Our benefits team at Walsh helps Western New York employers plan this exact communication strategy every fall. We can help you map your timeline, draft your announcement messages, and even sit with your employees at enrollment meetings to answer plan questions directly.

If your enrollment window is approaching and your communication plan is still a blank page, reach out to your Walsh advisor. We can help you put a proactive plan together.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How far in advance should we tell employees about open enrollment?

A: Three to four weeks before the window opens is a solid target. It gives employees time to review the guide without the announcement arriving so early that it gets forgotten.

Q: What should the first announcement include?

A: Keep it brief: the enrollment dates, what’s changing this year, where to find the guide, and who to contact with questions. Keep the deep details in the enrollment guide, and use your first email just to get people to open it.

Q: How should we explain a premium increase?

A: Directly. Show the old and new dollar amounts per pay period side by side. If you know the main driver of the increase, state it clearly in one sentence. Employees may not love the news, but they appreciate the transparency when real numbers are provided early.

Q: Most of our employees keep the same plan every year. Do we still need this communication plan?

A: Yes, because plans change even when your employees don’t. Deductibles shift, drug formularies are updated, and provider networks move. A clear summary of what changed protects employees who might otherwise assume everything stayed exactly the same.

Q: Should managers hear about enrollment changes before the rest of the team?

A: Yes. A quick heads-up before the first agency-wide announcement lets managers answer basic workflow questions and point people toward HR. It also allows them to carve out time for their teams to review the materials during the workday.